8.0
/ 10
the take
This is a strange, glittering paradox, both a satire of fame and one of the most instantly accessible indie pop records of its era. It walks a tightrope between irony and sincerity. Songs like Time to Pretend and Kids feel like anthems on the surface, but underneath, they’re quietly disillusioned, sketching out fantasies of youth, success, and excess, only to undercut them with a sense of emptiness. The writing is simple but that’s part of its charm. The album thrives on contrast. Bright synth lines, punchy drum programming, and psychedelic flourishes give it a candy-coated exterior, while the arrangements remain tight and purposeful. The band balances lo-fi indie textures with polished pop instincts, creating songs that are both immediate and slightly off-kilter. Tracks groove effortlessly, while deeper cuts lean more into warped, experimental territory. The album feels less like a narrative and more like a mood piece. It doesn’t fully commit to either satire or sincerity, but that tension is exactly what makes it resonate. It’s not perfect but at its best, it captures lightning in a bottle: a generation dancing to songs that are, quietly, about the illusion of the dance itself. Fav Track Time to Pretend
react and reply to Cole's review in the app
scan to open this review in Superfan
opens the app if installed, otherwise the App Store
new here?
discover, review, and share music with people who care about it as much as Cole does.